Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Trumpet Discussion' started by LeatherLips, Jan 10, 2012.
The longer the slide the greater the vacumn Cody
Okay, that makes sense, until I take in account that the 2nd valve slide seems to pop the loudest on almost all of the trumpets I play. But I dont go around and pop peoples slides.
I bet that has to do with the pitch of the pop ... shorter slide higher pitch ..... I can't believe I am actually talking about this.. I need to go practice...out
I have a Holton cornet from 1911 and it has essentially no compression any more. My grandfather used to oil it with spit. It is a great player though, in tune, secure feeling. The same more or less applies to my 1938 Heckel rotary Bb. Incredible player. That would imply a great overrating of compression when applied to the valves of trumpets.
Current building practice for rotary valve even has a hole drilled in the part of the valve casing not used for rerouting the standing wave. The valve no longer pop at all. Only the standing wave routes are really tightly sealed.
I am not sure that every trumpet needs snap, crackle, pop.
I wonder if players who can produce a tone more efficiently use less air which lessens the need for perfect compression.
okay I had my coffee, now so I am less grouchy
I wouldn't worry -- somehow I am reminded of this conversation once taking place: http://www.trumpetmaster.com/vb/f131/please-dont-laugh-how-do-you-60378.html
That's the 1st thing I thought. Being trumpet players, higher is better! 3rd valve slide would be the lowest pitch so may be perceived as less compressed. I have a Chas. George Vega with little to no compression but it still plays well. The trumpet that I've seen with the most/loudest pop was on the wall of a music store. It was a student horn and played poorly.
that's really impressive
Guys, all of you have completely ignored that the third valve slide is a longer than the first slide, therefore has a greater volume of air in it. You pull it out about the same amount and the vacuum in the first slide will be a lot higher.