rowuk

I think all of the rotary piccolo players will agree, due to the better airflow and reduced disturbance of the airstream, rotary valves work better. I also think it is easier to play a Scherzer more quietly than a Schilke or Stomvi (Getzen, Selmer.....).
If the recorder part is being played on a modern flute, it may not matter much, still generally the trumpet is too loud live. The natural trumpet in F has a tone color that blends better and Bach knew how to match the strengths and weaknesses of those old instruments, even a recorder has a chance with the original instrumentation!
I am sure you will do fine however you decide to play it. If you can borrow a (decent)rotary picc, I am sure you will see what I mean.

TrentAustin

just a quick note to let anyone who's interested I survived my first solo orchestra gig in 10 years last night. I didn't pass out or bleed even though it certainly left a lot to be desired.

I'm playing it again on Sunday and we'll see how it goes.

Thanks again everyone for all the tips.

-T

trumpetmike

Nice one Trent - any recording available?

I would love to hear you play this - the stuff I heard at ITG was stunning

TrentAustin

I have new clips from today's concert that are pretty decent.

I'll start a new post and hopefully y'all will check them out.

Best,

T