Dave,
I agree with your last post 100%! I was basing my previous comments on the "typical" BB gig that you, I, or most of the rest of the players here would get called to do. I fully understand the R&B thing. At one time I worked with a 9-piece Funk/B&B band that did all TP, EW&F, etc. stuff. That particular band started EVERY gig and ENDED every gig by playing an exact copy of Maynard's "Rocky". Try that sometime especially at the end of 5 hours!
I also agree that there are books out there that are more strenuous than others. I had my own BB for 7-8 years and we did all of the best charts from Maynard, Kenton, Herman, Rich, Thad Jones, etc. I would DEFINITELY categorize that book as an "A" book, but, again it was more the exception than the rule. I also agree with your "F/G" theory. To have a useable "F" you need to practice higher. At least I think that's what you meant. Around the time of my own BB I was very good friends with Jerry Callet. I gave hime a tape of this band from a recent 2 hour concert we had done. He went home and 3-4 days later called me up to tell me that he sat down and counted the number of double "G's" that I had played that night and the total was well over 150. Not for nothing but I wouldn't have lasted that book had I not practiced notes above the "G's". But I didn't get the impression from freshbrewed's post that he was looking to go play the lead book for the NTS 1:00 lab band!
So,again, I based my comments on what info I thought he might be looking for. I could be totally wrong and if I am I apologize for simplifying the "art of playing lead trumpet"!
BTW...I enjoy your reviews of the various brands of horns...keep them coming! Your reviews are all very intelligent and informative!
Butch