Thread: Playing Style
View Single Post
Old 03-29-2005, 01:19 PM   #3 (permalink)
JackD
Mezzo Forte User
 
JackD's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Manchester / London
Posts: 763
JackD is an unknown quantity at this point
Well to be honest I think the availablity of records is a great thing. I can reach for my cd collection and have the NY Phil Brass section or the CSO with Herseth coming through my stereo - not the same as seeing a live concert, but since these orchestras don't tour very often it's the closest I can get.

I think a lot of us UK types listen to the US orchestras, and some of my absolute favourite interpretations come from across the pond. That said, I'll be playing a Mahler symphony with an orchestra in the next few months, and I've been listening to an NYPO recording, a Weiner Phil one and have seen the LSO do it live - I'll try to draw something from everyone, but I'll still be using my Bb, and ultimately will still sound like me (unfortunately )

I think it's good in that hearing new recordings you might realise something about the piece you never noticed before - perhaps some slightly different emphasis in a phrase, or a completely different approach. The "danger" I suppose comes from a so-called "definitive" recording, which might cause people to imitate it - perhaps at the expense of differing interpretations.
JackD is offline   Reply With Quote