Thread: Monke Trumpets
View Single Post
Old 07-02-2005, 07:15 PM   #8 (permalink)
Dave Payn
New Friend
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Isle of Arran, Scotland
Posts: 48
Dave Payn is an unknown quantity at this point
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeroen Jongeling
Well, I'm not going to the Messe, but I do have a Monke Bflat trumpet.

The Monkes have been good trumpets for ages and still are quite good. But, lately, there are some other manufacturers that build better rotary trumpets. Let me point out Lechner and Schagerl. Lechner has been around now for some years and replaced Monke in most trumpetcases over the years. The upcoming horn that is replacing that one is the Schagerl.

I had the chance of testing the Schagerls a bit a short while ago (I was playing the Götterdämmerung and the trumpet section I sat in was testing them).

I started playing the opera on my Monke Bflat, but after a week of rehearsals I had the chance of playing a Lechner C (I borrowed that one of the first trumpeter, he didn't need it anymore because of the new Schagerls). I didn't switch back anymore and decided to sell my Monke and buy the Lechner.

If I had to choose right now I would buy a Schagerl (if only I had the money). They are fantastic! I would go for the Vienna modell. Put a Breslmair mouthpiece on it and you're good to go. Absolutely fabulous!

As for the Monke piston trumpets: I don't have a clue!

Jeroen.
I have (on extended loan) a Monke B flat which I am assured is at least 50 years old. Other than a tricky to pitch high Ab (probably my own doing!) I love it. I have to give it back soon but I've enjoyed playing it. I now own a Yamaha rotary valve Bb and that plays even better than the Monke.

Having said all that, I've never tried a Monke piston!
__________________
Amateur trumpeter
Cornet, Arran Brass
Brass band tutor for the Workers' Music Association Summer School

'When I'm down in the dumps, I just go and get myself a new hat.'
'I wondered where you got them from.'
Dave Payn is offline   Reply With Quote