Quote:
|
Originally Posted by peabodytrumpeter I think that teachers have been forced to "nice'n' up" by institutions. If they aren't nice to students, the students simply leave for another teacher that treats them well, but never raises their blood pressure. I really don't understand this! Students remember experiences, including getting thrown out of a lesson for not being prepared. Maybe that will light the fire under them to work!
I would much rather have a teacher that is always on my case and extremely invested in me than one that is "nice." |
These are really interesting points. I only half agree with them.
On one hand, having a teacher who is hard on you prepares you for the real world of playing. I think the students who studied with these type of teachers are less likely to freak out in a playing situation of any real pressure.
On the other hand, if your teacher is constantly slamming you (which is unlike any story have ever heard of Mundy), and not showing you any sign of belief in your abilities...you may end up feeling beaten and playing from a weakened position.
I think there are many fine teachers who are aware of this fine line and make an art out of walking that line in lessons.
Mike