View Single Post
Old 06-21-2007, 05:33 PM   #1 (permalink)
DSGerard
New Friend
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: soon to be in Arizona
Posts: 12
DSGerard will become famous soon enough
Focused but Free-blowing

My regular Bb set-up is a Bach 72* from the mid 90's. The horn plays great but mechanically is marginally better than a student horn. The slides are very stubborn (even after cleaning) and the valves are just so-so. I've had the horn close to 10 years so it's just something I have lived with. Enough Bach ranting.

I like the sound that I get on the horn but have always felt like it was a little too spread and lacked a certain amount of "weight". I've played and owned a number of Bach 37's and like the sound that I get but 37's have always felt stuffy to me.

I was in Nazareth Music a few weeks ago and tried out a Schilke S22 (L bore, ML bell) and man what a sweet horn! The schilke was free blowing, had a focused sound and a little more weight in the sound than my 72*. It did not however give much feedback, which my bach does. It felt great up top with just a little resistance to lean against. It got me thinking about what I like about my Bach, what I liked about the Schilke, and if there is anything out there in the middle.


*FINALLY TO THE QUESTIONS*

-In the meantime, can anyone offer a suggestion based on their experience, of a horn that has focus (sound), feedback, weight (sound), and is freeblowing.

-Are the playing characteristics of the Schilke due to the large bore and tighter bell as opposed to the Bach, ML bore, wider 72 bell?

-Should I suck it up and give myself 6 mos. on a 37 to get comfortable again?
-Does any of this make sense or am I chasing a unicorn?

-I plan on buying a horn in 3-6mos. so maybe I should just give Felix a call!

Gerard

Last edited by DSGerard; 06-21-2007 at 10:35 PM.
DSGerard is offline   Reply With Quote