View Single Post
Old 05-06-2008, 02:51 AM   #49 (permalink)
nordlandstrompet
Piano User
 
nordlandstrompet's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Norway
Posts: 313
nordlandstrompet has a spectacular aura aboutnordlandstrompet has a spectacular aura about
Re: the myth of "fast air"

Quote:
Originally Posted by kalijah View Post
Nordlands wrote:



Yes, the air flow is constant through the system, from lungs to bell. (With a minor exception)

And the speed can be determined anywhere by considering the cross section.

But you must be careful that you understand that because the air is "faster" through a narrow segment, this does not mean that the air has more energy due to this increase in speed due to "narrowing".

And it also becomes evident that the greatest velocity is through the aperture.

Also, increasing the narrowing anywhere in the system before the mp cup also increases the resistance and would yield a smaller flow for the same pressure. But usually not much less for most normal actions of tongue arch.

For example, tongue arch proponents make the claim that arching the tongue "speeds up" the air and the resulting "faster" air yields a higher pitch.

There are two faults to this way of thinking:

1. Arching the tongue will never increase the air energy at the aperture (total pressure) above what the lungs provide. and..

2. The pitch will not change unless the aperture pulsation frequency changes. The aperture itself must change. Namely, become smaller, to ascend.
Thanks for your clarifying answers.

Visualition and metafores has always been a efficient way of telling people how to act. This is also a reality for non brassplayers.

Ok. Next level:

Airflow: "The air is only active until it has left the lips. After this point, it lives its own life, (more or less inactive) inside the instrument, but follows some physical laws?"
__________________
nordlands

"All music is folkmusic. I ain't never heard no horse sing no song?" Louis Armstrong

Wife still says: Trumpets are expencive!
nordlandstrompet is offline   Reply With Quote