Quote:
Originally Posted by Doc Nelson  Forgive my ignorance, but what's the big difference between Prana and non...other than $100? I'm looking at getting a new mouthpiece, but not sure what would be a good combo for my horn (Cannonball RL). I want to play some jazz and I play a bit downstream although my usual posture is a little below center. |
The real question is what is different about a Monette mouthpiece - period. They are brass like every other brand, but Dave uses different geometry than other makers. The backbore is a different shape, the length of the throat and the transition from one part to another.
The standard Monette mouthpieces are designed with a different "intonation" than standard mouthpieces. If you play them the same way as the standard, you will notice that the low notes are a bit flat and the high notes a bit sharp. His take is that with standard mouthpieces, the player must change things in the body, breathing and embouchure to play in tune. Methods like the "pivot", TCE and others actually confirm this stand.
Using the Monette mouthpiece FORCES you to relax more (compensate less) in the upper register. That for many players results in increased range and endurance - or for those that don't let go of old habits, total frustration. That is why they are not for everybody. The time needed to adjust can be anywhere from a day or two to a couple of months. This is not a concept for a music store try out (actually no other mouthpiece or trumpet test should be either).
The Prana series is even more radical in the way they let the player tune and place notes. I would not recommend this series to be the first Monette piece ever - unless you are big on Yoga, martial arts or some other "mind over matter" hobby. It is surprising how much creeps into our playing (Monette or not) and how that affects everything else about what we need to do when playing.
I am really sold on Monette, but see why it is not the answer for some other players! You really have to want to work in that direction. If the sound and concept turn you on, they can be a BIG help in your development. If not, there are many other roads to success. I am happy that we have the choice!