So far you've gotten some very good advice on this forum. I believe it would be worth your while to find a good private instructor with a good track record.
As for the Balanced Embouchure method- I would think twice before commencing the study of this method, as it has had an extremely adverse effect on my playing, to put it mildly. Proceed at your own risk.
Good luck !
here's something you might want to try:
fix your lips and blow softly as if you're playing a note (but without the trumpet).
Now, slowly put the trumpet up to your lips as you blow softly. As the trumpet seals against the lips, the lips should begin to vibrate due to the resistance from the mouthpiece(vibrate isn't the exact term for what the lips do but its the term we'll go with right now). I'd venture to say that where you place the mouthpiece is what is most comfortable for you.
As for one size fits all balanced stuff? If it works for you, cool.
However, you might want to try this little experiment to see where your mouthpiece actually lands on your lips.
Exactly, most of these people do not really understand the full mechanics of how to play.
I have a problem with anyone that uses clichés and feeds off of other peoples frustration to push a product. I know the BE website has been updated recently, but the one he had before reminded me of those scammers that push miracle herbal cures to treat cancer. There are the naturals, who play by dumb luck, and there are the rest of us, thank god for the BE book to help the rest of us! What a load of crap.
Last edited by dizforprez; 11-09-2009 at 10:12 AM.
I'm with Veldkamp on this one. Bad air flow is one of the biggest problems in playing the horn, and one that is most often neglected. Get the student to loosen up on that tight glottis which is cutting off the air supply and you solved much of the getting a decent sound out of the horn.
Is this method good or not?
Bach Stradivarius 37 (1965), 43* (1974), 239 CML (1980)
Olds Ambassador Trumpet (1957) and Cornet (1957)
Getzen 896 Flugel (1974), 940 Piccolo, M2003ES Field Trumpet
Carol CPT-300LR Pocket Trumpet
Bach 3C, 3CFL mouthpieces
Once again, playing trumpet is an enjoyable experience for me, all thanks to The Balanced Embouchure.
Your results may vary; this is just my own experience with BE.
2010 Bach Stradivarius LR180S37
2005 Yamaha YTR-2335
Alessi-Akright Il Bocchino 3 (main MP)
For some people, BE clicks for them because they approach it with a useful mindset and figure out all the things that they need to get it working. I personally was not so lucky and had to work to get BE working for me. The exercises are easy to learn but the essence of BE isn't the exercises, it's what you manage to teach yourself from the exercises. Some people manage to teach themselves all the right things and progress very quickly, but others (like me) miss the point of the exercises and think the notes on the page are more important than what's happening with your chops.
I've also personally found that the support you can get from Jeff and the other BE dealers can be invaluable. I got quite a bit of help (for free) from Jeff, Ko and others while I was trying to figure out how to get some things working for myself.
It's my experience that BE works, but it is what you make it. If you work at it and use the available resources when needed, you can do well.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)