Seriously, your feedback on this solo will help me try to understand the concept you are making, as at this point, I am not understanding how the flugel is inferior to the trumpet a slotting for certain ranges and song types.
Thanks again for the time to listen and give me the feedback to help me understand.
Knowledge is freedom, and ignorance is slavery - Miles Davis
The difference between a beginner and pro mouthpiece is practice - tobylou8
Nobody has learned how to play the trumpet. It's endless. - Maynard Ferguson
Don't be afraid to try something different. The Ark was built by an amateur and the Titanic was built by a group of experienced engineers.
By the inch it's a cinch, by the yard, it's hard!
My point is a different one. A "slot" is when your instrument really "locks" into a note. Being able to nail it with hopeless abandon and its "crackability" minimal and intonation very solid. Trumpets actually do this very well. The length of the instrument, the bore size and bell taper make the standing wave very pronounced in its control of the lips.
A flugel on the other hand has a bell that is way too open and a leadpipe that is extremely short. The tones do not "lock in" in the manner a trumpet does. That is because the reduced stability of the standing wave. We have greater freedom to "bend" notes. Due to the fact that the flugel tone is not as directional as the trumpet, we actually hear ourselves better. That instills confidence and the impression is that the horn is better under control. Moving between notes on these conical bore instruments is easier because the "slot" is not as pronounced.
If I were to compare slotting to something else, it would be a piano for instance. Each individual tone locks in and when playing a lick, the move from one note to the next is very sharp in relation to intonation and resonance. That is the feeling from a fine trumpet. The individual notes seem to "pop" out. There is little "roundness" to the transition.
AS far as "hearing" slotting in a recording, that is a tough call. A good musician has "control" of the axe and their chops. The product is musically sound. Your recording is a good example of this. I would imagine that the same licks with a trumpet would have even more definition however. That is partly due to the additional overtones, and partly the more stable standing wave in the instrument.
Don't get me wrong, there is no definition lacking in what comes out of your bell. It is simply rounder than a trumpet.
So I guess my issue is if we call a slot the ability of the instrument to resonate quickly and sharply, that would be good for some players and not so good for others. "Good slotting" really depends on what the player is capable of. Weaker players will prefer rounder slots, stronger players can pick what fits their sound concept. For some it means easy to play, for others secure for yet others high definition of the individual tones. It is really a term that has no direct meaning.
In my case, I use my Getzen 4 valved flugel when I need a bit rounder and the medium bore rotary or Monette Prana when definition needs to be at its premium. My natural trumpet has the most pronounced "slots". I have to work hardest with it to change from note to note.
Whenever I feel blue, I start breathing again.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)